Gangs of New York : Blu-ray Review

The Movie Itself is directed by Martin Scorsese, of “The Departed“, “Goodfellas” and “Taxi Driver” fame.

I enjoy “Gangs of New York” but I certainly don’t love it, and I’m far from decreeing that it’s one of Scorsese’s best films. In truth, I think it’s actually one of his lesser films, but it still manages to present a unique and compelling story, with first-class acting talent that makes the epic-running time all the more tolerable.

Back when the film came out, I made the mistake of catching it at the last available screening on opening night. It wasn’t necessarily by choice. I had to wait for one of my friends to get out of work since I had promised to wait and see it with him.

When the film’s title finally hit the screen, and the lights went up, we filed out of our seats half asleep. It was obvious that we had made a mistake, and we knew that we’d have to see it again before we were to determine if we truly enjoyed the film, or not. At the same time though, we were certain of one thing, and that was Daniel Day Lewis. He lit the screen up, and delivered one of the most memorable film characters we’d ever seen. It’s funny how that’s almost common place for Day Lewis these days, but it’s a testament to his craft and skill.

When I finally got around to seeing the film again, I made sure to see it much earlier in the day, armed with an attentive mind. Much to my surprise however, I didn’t get nearly as much out of the second viewing as I had previously hoped. Many of my initial impressions still remained. Too long. Too ambiguous. Not memorable enough — despite the earnest efforts of the cast/crew.

Like I said before, I like the film, but I don’t love it like some fans do. As for why, I just think that an epic running time should support an epic story, and I don’t think the story is as epic as they would have you believe. In fact, I wouldn’t be surprised if someone else could come along and shoot the same story, and have the film clock in under 120 minutes in length. It’s heretical to suggest such a thing, I am aware, but I’m just stating my opinion. If the pacing issues were addressed, and needless scenes were removed, a more succinct and compelling picture would surface.

Regardless of my criticisms, the film retains a huge following, and also my admiration. The scope of the film is grand, and the origins of the New York gangs compelling — if only a tad slow.